Selling Mike Evans this week hands a contender his December for nothing cover
Back to Reality Sports Online Newsroom

Selling Mike Evans this week hands a contender his December for nothing

Kyle Shanahan called Evans week-to-week with Achilles tendinitis Wednesday, a day after the 49ers traded a sixth for Keenan Allen. Nora Pike says the Allen deal isn't a verdict on Evans, and she's holding unless he lands on IR.

Share this article

  • If somebody in your league texts you about Mike Evans tonight, don't answer. They aren't checking on your week. They saw Kyle Shanahan call Evans week-to-week on Wednesday, they saw the 49ers trade for Keenan Allen on Tuesday, and they've put those two together into the cheapest offer you'll get all year. I'd hold Evans, and I'd keep holding him until San Francisco tells me something worse than "week-to-week."

    The facts are thin, which is the point. Evans didn't practice Wednesday with Achilles tendinitis, and Shanahan said he's week-to-week, per Pro Football Talk. Yahoo had Shanahan saying there's no timeline. This has been building for a while. Shanahan said in October that Evans aggravated existing soreness against Washington, and he missed practice last Wednesday before being ruled out for the Raiders game. Pro Football Talk read the week-to-week label as Evans being out of consideration for Sunday at Dallas.

    I won't pretend that's nothing. An Achilles problem that's been managed for weeks on a veteran receiver can hang around all season, and if you're counting on Evans for Sunday, you've already lost that bet. Bench him. That part's easy.

    The part people get wrong is the Allen trade. The 49ers sent a 2027 sixth-round pick to Indianapolis for Allen on deadline day, per Tom Pelissero and Adam Schefter. The market is reading that as the team writing off Evans. Shanahan said Evans' injury didn't factor into the Allen deal, per Harrison Rich. You don't have to take a coach at his word, and I usually don't. But look at what they paid. A sixth for a 34-year-old with 40 catches for 351 yards in Indianapolis is a depth move, made for a room that has Christian Kirk on IR, Ricky Pearsall done for the year and Deebo Samuel just getting back to limited practice after missing three games.

    Separate the injury question from the contract question, because your league-mates won't. The injury question is how many weeks. Nobody knows, including the people texting you. The contract question is what Evans costs you to keep, and the answer is the same salary you're paying him whether he plays Sunday or not, plus a bench spot. Selling him today doesn't erase that money. It turns him into whatever a buyer will pay on the worst news day of his season, and I've never seen that number be a good one.

    If you're rebuilding, I get the itch. Evans was always going to be a this-season piece for you, and every week he sits is a week of value you can't get back. Even so, waiting costs you almost nothing. If the 49ers move him to IR, the offer you get next week will look a lot like tonight's. If he's back at limited practice before the Minnesota game, it won't.

  • Contenders should be even calmer. San Francisco is 7-1 and has been winning without him. The 49ers don't need to rush Evans, and that's good for you, because a receiver who comes back healthy in December matters more than one who limps through November.

    So I'm holding, and I'd tell you to do the same. If the 49ers put him on IR this week, come find me and tell me I was wrong. I'll take it. Until then, the only person who should be excited about a Mike Evans trade is the one trying to buy him.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.