Selling David Montgomery because he skipped the Cleveland trip is how you get fleeced cover
Back to Reality Sports Online Newsroom

Selling David Montgomery because he skipped the Cleveland trip is how you get fleeced

Houston ruled David Montgomery out Saturday and left him home from Cleveland after two days of practice. Nora Pike says the short week explains the call better than a setback does, and the panic price is the one to avoid.

Share this article

  • Somebody in your league is going to read that David Montgomery won't travel to Cleveland and decide the comeback is over. I'd let them think it for about 48 hours, and I wouldn't sell him to them at the price they're about to offer. A back who's practiced twice in a month and then stays home from a 1 p.m. road game four days before a Thursday night game isn't telling you his groin is ruined. He's telling you his team didn't want his first game back to be the front half of a short week.

    Here's what's on the record. Ian Rapoport and Adam Schefter both posted Saturday that Houston ruled Montgomery out for Sunday at Cleveland with the groin injury, and Rapoport added he won't make the trip. He's been out since he got hurt against the Titans on Oct. 11, and the Texans already ruled him out for the Chargers in Week 9. Thursday was the first time he practiced, mostly side work according to the Houston reporters who saw it, and Aaron Wilson posted that he was back out there Friday. Wilson also has Woody Marks starting Sunday, with Emari Demercado behind him, after Marks missed practice time with knee soreness and drew no injury designation.

  • Our news desk called Saturday a step back, and I understand why. Two days of practice followed by a no-go looks like a setback from the outside, and a groin that already cost him a month doesn't earn the benefit of the doubt. If you think the injury is lingering, that's a fair read and I won't pretend I know otherwise. Nobody outside that building has reported a new problem, and nobody has reported that he's fine either.

    But look at the calendar Houston is staring at. Sunday in Cleveland, then the Colts at home on Thursday, Nov. 19. I've watched plenty of staffs make this exact call. You don't bring a veteran back from a month off for two games in five days when the guy behind him can carry the load for one more Sunday. To me that looks like a team managing a ramp-up. It's the boring explanation, which in my experience is usually the right one.

    The injury question and the contract question are separate, and the second one is where people lose trades. Whatever you're paying Montgomery in your RSO league didn't change Saturday. What changed is how cheap he looks for the next couple of days, and cheap only lasts while everyone's reading the same headline. If a league-mate offers you a real return, fine, take it. If they're offering you a rookie flier and a sympathetic text, they're buying your patience at a discount.

    I'll admit what this costs. If Montgomery misses Thursday too, I'll have told you to sit on a back while his value dropped another notch, and you'll be right to bring it up. I'd still rather be wrong by waiting than be the manager who sold a starter because he skipped a flight.

  • Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.