A.J. Brown's next healthy practice is your last good chance to sell him cover
Back to Reality Sports Online Newsroom

A.J. Brown's next healthy practice is your last good chance to sell him

A.J. Brown left the Patriots' 35-10 loss in Munich with a hamstring injury, his third separate injury this season. Vic Castellano says don't dump him tonight, sell him the day he's back on the practice field.

Share this article

  • Don't sell A.J. Brown tonight. Sell him the first day he's back on a practice field, when everyone in your league is busy being relieved.

    Brown left Sunday's 35-10 loss to the Lions in Munich with a hamstring injury and didn't come back. Mike Reiss posted the Patriots' questionable-to-return call, Doug Kyed had him out for the day not long after, and Andrew Callahan posted that Brown left the locker room with a limp. There's no diagnosis yet, no MRI result and no timeline.

  • That's exactly why tonight is the worst price you'll ever get. Your league-mates read the same posts you did. Whatever lands in your inbox before Wednesday is priced off a limp and a blank injury report, and you'd be handing Brown to the one manager in your league patient enough to wait. Reiss also noted New England has its bye next week, so holding through it costs you nothing extra. He wasn't going to score for you next Sunday either way.

    Here's why I'm selling anyway once he's upright. This is his third separate injury of the season. A high ankle sprain put him on injured reserve in September. A knee cost him the Week 8 and Week 9 games. He got back to a limited practice Wednesday, played Sunday, and then the hamstring went in Munich. I'm not a doctor, and three different body parts don't add up to a diagnosis. Maybe it's three rounds of bad luck. Your lineup doesn't care. It scores Sundays played, and Brown keeps losing his to the training room.

    Then there's the guy throwing to him. Drake Maye left on the opening drive with an ankle injury of his own, and Mike Vrabel said Maye will get more tests once the team is back from Germany. A receiver's value in a contract league rides on his quarterback, and right now nobody can tell you who that is for New England after the bye.

    The case for holding is a good one, and I'll give it its due. The bye buys a soft-tissue injury an extra week. A healthy Brown is still the kind of receiver you start every week without thinking, and selling that kind of player a week early has burned me before. I once dumped a hurt star in November and watched him beat me in the semifinals. I still hear about it.

  • But holding means betting on the Brown you remember, and nobody's going to pay you for him. What they'll pay for is the next healthy practice. That's the day his name shows up on the report without a designation, the worry drains out of your league chat, and somebody starts picturing the Brown they drafted. That manager is your buyer, and he won't stay that eager for long.

    If Brown comes back and carries a contender through December, I'll own being early, loudly. I'd still rather sell a star a week too soon than pay his salary into another offseason on the hope that his fourth injury never shows up. So keep your phone face down tonight. The day he's practicing again, start making calls.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.