Selling Justin Herbert over his non-throwing finger is how you get fleeced cover
Back to Reality Sports Online Newsroom

Selling Justin Herbert over his non-throwing finger is how you get fleeced

Justin Herbert is being tested on the middle finger of his left hand after an eight-sack loss left the Chargers 0-8. Nora Pike says the finger is a one-week question and the 0-8 is the real one, so nobody should sell him at today's price.

Share this article

  • If someone in your league offers you a discount on Justin Herbert today, take it. If you own Herbert and you're thinking about selling him today, put the phone down. A middle finger on his non-throwing hand is the least important thing that happened to him on Sunday, and it's the only thing anybody is pricing.

    Here's what we actually know. Herbert hurt the middle finger on his left hand in the fourth quarter of a 44-22 loss to Houston, and DJ Uiagalelei finished the game. Jim Harbaugh said afterward it "could be a fracture" and that they'd find out. Adam Schefter had Herbert going for testing on Monday. Herbert, for his part, said it shouldn't be an issue, and Harbaugh said Herbert wanted back in and that pulling him was the coach's call.

  • That's the whole injury file. The test isn't back. Nobody has said he'll miss a snap, and the Chargers don't play again until Monday night, Nov. 16, at Baltimore. He throws with his right hand. I can't tell you what the scan shows, and neither can the manager who's about to shop him to you at a markdown. That's exactly why the price is wrong this morning.

    The finger is a one-week question. The real problem is a different conversation, and it's the one worth having.

    Herbert was sacked eight times Sunday. He went 13 of 23 for 193 yards with a touchdown and an interception before he came out, and the Chargers are now 0-8 after C.J. Stroud threw five touchdowns on them in their own building. That's the part of this I'd lose sleep over if I had Herbert on a long contract in a dynasty league. A quarterback who gets hit that often is one bad landing away from hurting the hand he throws with. And an 0-8 team in November is a team that could look very different by next fall, starting with the line in front of him, which nobody in your league can price today.

    So keep those two questions apart. The finger question says hold, because you'd be selling into the one week when the news is scariest and least known. The 0-8 question might say sell, and if it does, it says sell later, at full price, after the test comes back and Herbert's back on the field.

  • I've earned some humility on this kind of call. I told you to buy Saquon Barkley in late October and then had to admit I was buying a trend, not a dip. This one's different in the way that matters. Barkley's problem was showing up on the field week after week. Herbert's is a scan nobody has read yet, on the hand he doesn't throw with.

    If you're the buyer, move before Monday night in Baltimore, because that discount disappears the moment he takes a snap. If you're the seller, wait until he does, then decide whether you believe in the Chargers more than you believe in the man throwing for them. Those are two different bets, and only one of them should cost you a quarterback this week.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.