Josh Downs got his trade to Mahomes, and that's exactly why you sell him cover
Back to Reality Sports Online Newsroom

Josh Downs got his trade to Mahomes, and that's exactly why you sell him

Kansas City sent 2027 fourth- and fifth-round picks to Indianapolis for Josh Downs on deadline day. Vic Castellano told you to buy him two weeks ago, and now he says cash out while the Mahomes headline does your selling.

Share this article

  • Sell Josh Downs this week. I told you to buy him on Oct. 28, before anyone had moved him, because a trade was going to raise his price. Kansas City made the trade on Tuesday, and his price went up. That was the plan, and the plan always had a second half.

    The deal itself was small. The Chiefs sent 2027 fourth- and fifth-round picks to Indianapolis for Downs and a 2027 seventh, per Tom Pelissero and Adam Schefter. That's what real NFL front offices think a rental slot receiver is worth on deadline day. Your league doesn't think that way. Your league sees "Downs to Mahomes" and starts typing. Let them type.

    Here's why I'm not holding. Downs' contract runs out after this season, ESPN notes, so in a contract league you own the rest of this season and a question mark. Where he signs next spring decides his 2027 value, and neither you nor the guy offering for him knows the answer. Right now that uncertainty gets priced like upside. By March it'll be priced like risk.

    Then look at what Kansas City was shopping for. ESPN says Patrick Mahomes hasn't completed a pass of more than 20 air yards since Week 4, and he averaged 2.8 air yards per attempt in last week's win over the Jets. Tyquan Thornton, the Chiefs' best deep threat early on, had surgery on a dislocated ankle. Downs is a quickness and route-running guy who does his best work from the slot. He's a good player who fixes the problem the Chiefs already had the least of.

    The case for keeping him is real, so I'll make it for you. Downs averaged 66 catches and 713.3 yards over his first three seasons. Mahomes is a major upgrade on what he had in Indianapolis. Xavier Worthy left the Jets game late with a hamstring injury, so there could be targets lying around in Atlanta on Sunday. And Downs already torched this team once, with seven catches on nine targets for 72 yards against Kansas City in Week 2.

    I'll grant every bit of that and still sell, because of this season's line: 33 catches on 56 targets, 354 yards, one touchdown and a career-low 57.9% catch rate. ESPN puts part of that on Alec Pierce being out and defenses keying on Downs, which is fair. It's also the production you're actually selling. The offers you'll get this week aren't paying for that line. They're paying for the new jersey. Downs goes from leading the Colts in receiving yards to being the new guy learning an offense, and whenever Worthy's back, he's splitting the ball with him.

  • Could I be wrong? Absolutely. If he catches eight balls in Atlanta, his price climbs again and I look early. I'd rather be early than be the guy still holding an expiring contract in March, wondering where the market went.

    So put him on the block today with one condition: you want a player under contract for 2027 coming back, not a pick swap and a thank-you note. If nobody bites on those terms, keep him and enjoy the ride. Somebody in your league probably texted you about him last night, though. Answer that text with a price.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.