Marvin Harrison Jr. is cheap again. That doesn't make him a bargain cover
Back to Reality Sports Online Newsroom

Marvin Harrison Jr. is cheap again. That doesn't make him a bargain

Houston ruled Marvin Harrison Jr. out of Thursday night's game against the Colts, his second straight absence with a hamstring injury. Nora Pike says his role, not the hamstring, is holding his price down, and she's in no hurry to buy.

Share this article

  • I usually tell you cheap is a moment and you'd better move before it passes. Marvin Harrison Jr. is my exception. He's cheap this week, he'll probably still be cheap in two weeks, and the reason has less to do with his hamstring than everyone in your league thinks.

    The Texans ruled Harrison out Wednesday for Thursday night's game against the Colts. It's his second straight missed game with the same hamstring that kept him out of Sunday's loss in Cleveland, and RotoWire points to Nov. 29 against Baltimore as his next chance to play. Nobody in your league learns anything new about him for 10 days, and the owner who's fed up with him won't get more patient in the meantime.

    Houston paid a real price for him. On Oct. 12 the Texans sent Arizona a 2027 second-round pick and a 2027 seventh and got Harrison and a 2027 sixth back, per ESPN's Adam Schefter. DeMeco Ryans called him "a really good player." Then Houston threw him 11 passes in three games. RotoBaller had him at six catches for 60 yards and a touchdown before the hamstring, and in the Cleveland game he missed, Nico Collins and Xavier Hutchinson saw 25 targets between them.

    That's the part I'd pull apart from the injury. The hamstring is a short-term question, and short-term questions are what nervous owners sell into. The role is the long-term question, and it's the one that sets his price. A receiver who gets fewer than four looks a game when he's healthy doesn't get more valuable just because he got healthy.

    The case for buying is a good one, so I'll make it properly. He's 24. He went fourth overall in 2024. RotoWire's preseason outlook argued that plenty went wrong in Arizona that wasn't his fault, starting with a heel injury that held him to three appearances and 85 snaps after Week 10 last season, and that before it he was averaging 4.0 catches and 59.4 yards over his first 10 games. Across both teams this year he has 11 catches for 145 yards and two touchdowns on 24 targets. If you believe the talent wins eventually, you can talk yourself into this being the dip.

    I can talk myself into it too, for about a minute. What stops me is the contract clock. He signed a four-year rookie deal in May 2024, so this is his third season on it, and he's spent a lot of it either hurt or waiting for the ball. Every week in the trainer's room is a week he isn't building his case in a new offense. In a league where your contract on him has years left, that's a cost you're paying whether he plays or not.

  • If you already own him, don't sell into this. You'd be taking the floor price for a question nobody can answer until Nov. 29. If you don't, let the other managers chase the draft slot. Wait until you've seen what Houston does with him on a clean injury report. If that first game comes with eight targets, you'll pay more, and I'm fine with that, because you'll be paying for something you watched happen.

    I've missed the bottom on players this way before, and I might miss it here. I'd still rather pay for a role I've seen than for a draft night I remember.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.