Giants QB J.J. McCarthy is questionable to return with a hip injury cover
Back to Reality Sports Online Newsroom

Giants QB J.J. McCarthy is questionable to return with a hip injury

The Giants quarterback went to the medical tent and then the locker room during Sunday's game at the Philadelphia Eagles. Jameis Winston entered in his place after McCarthy collapsed while throwing on the sideline.

Share this article

  • New York Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy is questionable to return from a hip injury during Sunday's game at the Philadelphia Eagles, Ian Rapoport of NFL Network said Sunday afternoon. Underdog NFL posted the same hip designation after McCarthy left the field.

  • Mike Garafolo of NFL Network said McCarthy went into the Giants' medical tent after a replay showed him collapsing while throwing on the sideline, and that McCarthy reached for his side as he went down. Underdog NFL first said he was heading to the tent, then said he went to the locker room. Jameis Winston entered the game in McCarthy's place, Underdog NFL said.

    ESPN's in-game injury report lists McCarthy as questionable with an undisclosed injury. Rapoport and Underdog NFL both identified the injury as a hip issue. The Giants have not said he is ruled out.

    Before he left, ESPN's box score had McCarthy 9 of 13 for 101 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions. He was sacked five times for a loss of 29 yards and ran three times for 11 yards. After Winston took over, ESPN had him 5 of 7 for 66 yards, one sack for a loss of six yards and two rushes for 11 yards. Those numbers posted in the third quarter, with the Giants trailing 8-6.

    McCarthy started Sunday at Philadelphia. Winston is the veteran backup who started earlier this season and is now running the offense.

    What is confirmed: McCarthy left Sunday's game, he was checked in the medical tent, he went to the locker room, Winston is playing, and both Rapoport and Underdog NFL list him as questionable to return with a hip injury. ESPN lists the same questionable status. The club has not said whether he will come back later Sunday.

  • What RSO owners should do now: if your league locked lineups before the 1 p.m. ET window, McCarthy is already a live risk and Winston is the quarterback in the game. If you can still move a flexible or later-lock roster, sit McCarthy until there is a clear return and start Winston if he is on your roster. In dynasty and contract leagues, hold McCarthy while the hip evaluation plays out and treat Winston as the short-term fill-in until more is known.

    What to watch next: whether the Giants rule McCarthy out or he returns Sunday; any postgame word on the hip; and his practice status when New York returns to work this week, which will shape his Week 10 outlook.